Top Research Professionals
The research experts and assignment help team consists exclusively of highly qualified graduate writers, each professional with in-depth subject matter expertise and significant experience in custom academic writing.
For similar papers and sample answers; with a few clicks, Order your research paper, thesis, dissertation writing and other assignment help services
Posted: May 1st, 2022
Verlinden’s Tests of Evidence
When creating an argument or analyzing an argument, the presence of evidence is not enough: One must analyze the strength and validity of the evidence. Whenever you look at any piece of evidence or citation, consider the following six areas when evaluating a source (Verlinden, 2005):
Source Credibility
– Does source have the appropriate background?
– Does the source have the required knowledge?
– Does the source have sufficient expertise?
Source Bias
-Does the source represent a particular interest or perspective?
-Does the source claim objectivity?
-Does the source have preconceived ideas that may color their judgment?
-What “invisible” biases might exist (how does culture or upbringing influence it)?
Recency
-Does the evidence come from the appropriate time period?
Internal Consistency
-Are there any contradictory statements in the source?
Completeness
-Is enough information provided?
-Does the original source provide some background information?
Corroboration (a.k.a. external consistency)
-Do other qualified sources agree with the evidence?
Source: Verlinden, J. (2005) Critical Thinking and Everyday Argument. Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth
The CRAAP Test
The CRAAP test is a handy acronym you can use to evaluate websites or other sources:
-Currency: Similar to the recency test from Verlinden, is the source current (where appropriate)
-Relevance: How closely tied to your subject is this source? Is it tangential or not?
-Authority: Is the source qualified to speak/write on this topic? (similar to “source credibility” from Verlinden)
-Accuracy: How reliable and truthful is this information? (This combines internal and external consistency from Verlinden)
-Purpose: Why does this source exist in the first place? What’s the motivation behind it?
Study Notes, Research Topics & Assignment Examples: Case 1 Due February 7th International Business Management »Guidelines for Writing a Literary Critical AnalysisWe prioritize delivering top quality work sought by college students.
The research experts and assignment help team consists exclusively of highly qualified graduate writers, each professional with in-depth subject matter expertise and significant experience in custom academic writing.
Our custom writing services maintain the highest quality while remaining affordable for students. Our pricing for research papers, theses, and dissertations is not only fair considering the superior quality but also competitive with other writing services.
We guarantee plagiarism-free, human-written content. Every product is assured to be original and not AI-generated. Our writers, tutors and editors are research experts who ensures the right formating and citation sytles are followed. To note, all the final drafts undergo rigorous plagiarism checks before delivery for submission to ensure authenticity for our valued customers.
When you decide to place an order with Dissertation Help, here is what happens: